• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Lifestyle
Steven Pinker on the Tribal Roots of Defying Social Distancing thumbnail

Steven Pinker on the Tribal Roots of Defying Social Distancing

July 20, 2020
Trump Allies Rally Around Former President After Indictment thumbnail

Trump Allies Rally Around Former President After Indictment

March 31, 2023
House Democrats vent frustration after Biden reversal on COVID-19 emergency measure thumbnail

House Democrats vent frustration after Biden reversal on COVID-19 emergency measure

March 31, 2023
White House slams House GOP over budget delays in debt-ceiling impasse thumbnail

White House slams House GOP over budget delays in debt-ceiling impasse

March 31, 2023
Italy-sized chunk of Gulf of Mexico to be auctioned off by the US for oil drilling thumbnail

Italy-sized chunk of Gulf of Mexico to be auctioned off by the US for oil drilling

March 30, 2023
Elizabeth Warren running for 3rd US Senate term in 2024 thumbnail

Elizabeth Warren running for 3rd US Senate term in 2024

March 29, 2023
Washington bill would restrict the sale of health data thumbnail

Washington bill would restrict the sale of health data

March 29, 2023
White House Suggests ‘Assault Weapons Ban’ After Mass Shooting at Nashville School thumbnail

White House Suggests ‘Assault Weapons Ban’ After Mass Shooting at Nashville School

March 28, 2023
Dem Rep. Cohen: 'Hard' to Serve with GOP So 'Attached to Guns,' They’re 'Part of the Danger' thumbnail

Dem Rep. Cohen: ‘Hard’ to Serve with GOP So ‘Attached to Guns,’ They’re ‘Part of the Danger’

March 28, 2023
Analysis-Banking woes, Fed keep investors on edge in nervous U.S. stock market thumbnail

Analysis-Banking woes, Fed keep investors on edge in nervous U.S. stock market

March 28, 2023
Marjorie Taylor Greene Says She Was 'Assaulted' by Whistle at DC Jail Visit thumbnail

Marjorie Taylor Greene Says She Was ‘Assaulted’ by Whistle at DC Jail Visit

March 27, 2023
Boston Red Sox Star Achieves Big Spring Training Milestone Less Than 3 Weeks After Gruesome Injury thumbnail

Boston Red Sox Star Achieves Big Spring Training Milestone Less Than 3 Weeks After Gruesome Injury

March 27, 2023
A better solution to fraud and chargebacks than regulation thumbnail

A better solution to fraud and chargebacks than regulation

March 27, 2023
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • Donate
Friday, March 31, 2023
66 °f
Wellfleet
58 ° Tue
63 ° Wed
68 ° Thu
61 ° Fri
  • Login
  • Register
FREE Cape Cod News
DONATE
  • FREE Cape Cod News
  • News
    • News
    • Cape Cod News
    • Massachusetts
    • Breaking News
    • Cape Cod Weather
    • Storm Watch
    • Environment
  • Politics
    • democrats
    • republicans
  • Business
    • business
    • cryptocurrency
    • economy
    • money
    • Real Estate
    • Tech
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Photos
    • Orleans
    • Eastham
    • Wellfleet
    • Truro
    • Provincetown
    • Brewster
    • Chatham
  • Videos
No Result
View All Result
Free Cape Cod News
No Result
View All Result
  • FREE Cape Cod News
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Photos
  • Videos
Home Lifestyle Nature

Steven Pinker on the Tribal Roots of Defying Social Distancing

FREE Cape Cod News by FREE Cape Cod News
July 20, 2020
in Nature
Reading Time: 5 mins read
Donate
0
Steven Pinker on the Tribal Roots of Defying Social Distancing thumbnail
635
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
Partly because people think of experts as oracles, as opposed to experimenters and exploiters of trial and error, there’s a presumption that either the experts know what is the best policy from the get-go, or else they are incompetent and ought to be replaced.Photograph by GoToVan / Flickr

The images are everywhere: People crowded face-to-face in swimming pools, shoulder-to-shoulder in indoor bars, cheering without masks at a rally held by President Trump, who often downplays the global pandemic. Now, as many public health experts predicted, waves of new COVID-19 infections and deaths are rolling across the South and West. Many, still practicing social distancing, look at their fellow Americans and ask, “What are they thinking?”

We turned to Steven Pinker for help with an answer. The professor of psychology at Harvard, author of widely discussed books, including How the Mind Works and most recently, Enlightenment Now, sees the deep-seated mindset, tribalism, at work in people’s defiance of health recommendations. But it’s more than a tribalism of being with your crowd. “There’s a moralistic component to this kind of tribalism, mainly that people tend to see their own tribes as victims of some kind of oppression or harm by some rival coalition,” Pinker says, his distinctive mass of gray hair filling the Zoom screen. “They believe their actions on behalf of the group, even if symbolic, are a kind of justice, a kind of settling the score, making a statement, advancing a moral cause—as strange as that may be to those of us who are not part of that coalition, and might even have contempt for that cause. But from the inside, it always feels as if your group has been victimized, has been a longstanding victim of a series of affronts and harms for which you seek redress. And that’s common in the invented histories and myths and narratives of many peoples.”

When there is some belief that is incompatible with the belief, ‘I’m in control, I’m good, I’m competent,’ that’s when the rationalizations go into overdrive.

Pinker says it can be easier to understand the effect of tribalism by putting the shoe on the other foot. “Some of the people on the political right could, indeed, ask that question of the people showing up at Black Lives Matter rallies. They’re crowded together. They’re shouting. They’re chanting. A lot of them are not wearing masks. If we imagine answering that person’s question from the point of view of our buddies on the street protesting that Black Lives Matter, we can get probably some insight, even if we have our loyalties as to which is a legitimate cause and which is the not-so-legitimate cause. But you’re asking about psychology, about what people could possibly be thinking. Well, what could they be thinking in the street, shouting slogans without a mask? What could the public health experts be thinking, telling people it’s OK to do that?”

Science is continually butting heads with politics and religion. The COVID-19 crisis is foremost on our minds now. But climate change, vaccination, and genetically modified food are also cultural battlefields du jour. Dan Kahan, a professor of law and psychology at Yale, heads the Cultural Cognition Project at the university, which explores how cultural values shape public risk perceptions. He has shown, time and again, that the need to belong to a group, usually political or religious, overrides the facts of science. Kahan, who was unable to be interviewed, has written in Nature: “People find it disconcerting to believe that behavior that they find noble is nevertheless detrimental to society, and behavior that they find base is beneficial to it. Because accepting such a claim could drive a wedge between them and their peers, they have a strong emotional predisposition to reject it.”

Pinker agrees, but stresses that doing the right thing is never easy for anybody. “With coronavirus, it’s genuinely hard to know whether surfaces are potential vectors, whether six feet is enough or not enough, whether masks help or don’t help,” Pinker says. “From a scientist’s point of view, it’s not surprising the information would shift. That’s because our natural state is ignorance. We can only learn from data, and as the data comes in, our state of knowledge and best practices will change. But, partly because people think of experts as oracles, as opposed to experimenters and exploiters of trial and error, there’s a presumption that either the experts know what is the best policy from the get-go, or else they are incompetent and ought to be replaced. That’s opposed to what we know to be the correct situation in science—namely, no one knows anything, and you have to learn.”

But even learning, Pinker adds, doesn’t guarantee confidence. “As Kahan has shown, even those of us who think we have enlightened beliefs on evolution, climate change, coronavirus, don’t have the expertise to come to a reasoned conclusion,” Pinker says. “So we trust the scientists. And we’re right to do so because scientists do have methods more likely to lead to the truth than the conspiracy theorists and kooks. But if you don’t have solidarity with The New York Times, NBC, CNN, Harvard University, and the World Health Organization—you think they’re just another interest group or just another tribe—then you’ll be receptive to some alternative source of information. Just like people with respectable beliefs trust the public health scientists.”

Leon Festinger, a psychologist, coined in the 1950s one of the most famous terms in psychology, “cognitive dissonance.” Over many years and in many experiments, Festinger proved that when faced with an inconvenient truth about an action they wish to take, people will inevitably devise a rationalization to support their action. (Festinger, whom I had the honor of knowing, was a heavy smoker, a textbook example of cognitively dissonant behavior: smoking even though you believe it will give you cancer. Festinger died at age 69 of cancer.)

Pinker says motivations in the age of COVID-19 go beyond cognitive dissonance. “It isn’t just that people are logicians and they’re bothered by contradictions,” he offers. “They’re really bothered by facts that seem to challenge their self-image as competent, autonomous, and moral. I think the better interpretation of Festinger’s findings is not so much that all your thoughts have to be consistent. Probably a lot of our thoughts aren’t consistent. We just don’t think them through. But when there is some belief that is incompatible with the belief, ‘I’m in control, I’m good, I’m competent,’ that’s when the rationalizations go into overdrive.”

And, Pinker contends, rationalizations almost invariably take the rosy, individualistic view. “A lot of people don’t wear seat belts. Which is foolish because the outcome of an accident could be catastrophic. But people are correct in thinking that, more likely than not, they won’t be killed in a car crash. Part of it is that the individual risk is low. But it is foolish collectively. And unlike a car crash, getting infected with the coronavirus could be endangering others.”

Can people change? “The question might be, ‘Does a reduction in cognitive dissonance, rationalization, have some kind of finite elasticity?” Pinker says. “Can you stretch it only so far before it actually will break? And I think the answer has to be ‘Yes.’ Take the doomsday cult that Festinger infiltrated in 1950 that was the basis for the theory of cognitive dissonance. Namely, what happens to the cult members on December 31, when the world doesn’t come to an end? Now what do you do? A lot of them doubled down, but a lot of them didn’t. People left the cult. So that can happen. There is a reality principle. We can push back against it so far, but opinions do change when they have a major collision with the facts.”

Robert Bazell is an adjunct professor of molecular, cellular, and developmental biology at Yale. For 38 years, he was chief science correspondent for NBC News.

Get the Nautilus newsletter

The newest and most popular articles delivered right to your inbox!

FREE Digital Newspaper Subscription!
Sign up for your free digital subscription. The FREE Cape Cod News

Unsubscribe
FREE Cape Cod News

FREE Cape Cod News

Free Cape Cod News is what's happening in the Cape Cod, U.S and World & what people are talking about right now. Local newspaper. Stay in the know. Subscribe to get notified about our latest news.

Related Posts

How can you tell a dolphin’s age? Check its freckles. thumbnail
Nature

How can you tell a dolphin’s age? Check its freckles.

by FREE Cape Cod News
March 26, 2023
Hubble spotted a runaway supermassive black hole for the first time ever thumbnail
Nature

Hubble spotted a runaway supermassive black hole for the first time ever

by FREE Cape Cod News
March 24, 2023
Astronomers sound alarm about light pollution from satellites thumbnail
Nature

Astronomers sound alarm about light pollution from satellites

by FREE Cape Cod News
March 22, 2023
America used to have its own lion. Where did they go? thumbnail
Nature

America used to have its own lion. Where did they go?

by FREE Cape Cod News
March 20, 2023
Load More
Please login to join discussion

Follow Us on Twitter

FREE Cape Cod News - Your source for local Cape Cod news, latest breaking U.S. and World news. Every day, all day. Subscribe for your favorite categories.

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Red States Benefit Most From Biden's Inflation Reduction Act thumbnail

Red States Benefit Most From Biden’s Inflation Reduction Act

March 1, 2023
Trump Allies Rally Around Former President After Indictment thumbnail

Trump Allies Rally Around Former President After Indictment

March 31, 2023
What is the weather like in Cape Cod in September. FREE Cape Cod News.

What is Special about Cape Cod?

March 2, 2023
Trump Allies Rally Around Former President After Indictment thumbnail

Trump Allies Rally Around Former President After Indictment

March 31, 2023
House Democrats vent frustration after Biden reversal on COVID-19 emergency measure thumbnail

House Democrats vent frustration after Biden reversal on COVID-19 emergency measure

March 31, 2023
White House slams House GOP over budget delays in debt-ceiling impasse thumbnail

White House slams House GOP over budget delays in debt-ceiling impasse

March 31, 2023

FREE Cape Cod News On Twitter

Today’s News

  • Trump Allies Rally Around Former President After Indictment March 31, 2023
  • House Democrats vent frustration after Biden reversal on COVID-19 emergency measure March 31, 2023
  • White House slams House GOP over budget delays in debt-ceiling impasse March 31, 2023
  • Italy-sized chunk of Gulf of Mexico to be auctioned off by the US for oil drilling March 30, 2023
  • Elizabeth Warren running for 3rd US Senate term in 2024 March 29, 2023
FREE Cape Cod News

Copyright © 2022 Free Cape Cod News

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • Donate

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • FREE Cape Cod News
  • News
    • News
    • Cape Cod News
    • Massachusetts
    • Breaking News
    • Cape Cod Weather
    • Storm Watch
    • Environment
  • Politics
    • democrats
    • republicans
  • Business
    • business
    • cryptocurrency
    • economy
    • money
    • Real Estate
    • Tech
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Photos
    • Orleans
    • Eastham
    • Wellfleet
    • Truro
    • Provincetown
    • Brewster
    • Chatham
  • Videos
  • Login
  • Sign Up

Copyright © 2022 Free Cape Cod News

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist