• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Lifestyle
The Trouble with Counting Alien Civilizations thumbnail

The Trouble with Counting Alien Civilizations

July 20, 2020
Record cold snap could hit New England this weekend thumbnail

Record cold snap could hit New England this weekend

February 3, 2023
Joe Biden Offered Vladimir Putin 20 Percent of Ukraine to End War: Report thumbnail

Joe Biden Offered Vladimir Putin 20 Percent of Ukraine to End War: Report

February 3, 2023
GoodRx fined $1.5 million for allegedly selling users’ health data thumbnail

GoodRx fined $1.5 million for allegedly selling users’ health data

February 3, 2023
Small Businesses Lost 75,000 Jobs in January thumbnail

Small Businesses Lost 75,000 Jobs in January

February 2, 2023
DARPA wants to push the boundaries of where satellites can fly thumbnail

DARPA wants to push the boundaries of where satellites can fly

February 2, 2023
Pamela Anderson says she and Kid Rock broke up over her 'Borat' cameo thumbnail

Pamela Anderson says she and Kid Rock broke up over her ‘Borat’ cameo

February 2, 2023
Biden and McCathy's debt-ceiling talk is a clash of strategies thumbnail

Biden and McCathy’s debt-ceiling talk is a clash of strategies

February 2, 2023
Doc Re-Used Nasal Surgery Devices; Humira Patent Game; Nonprofit Hospital Tactics thumbnail

Doc Re-Used Nasal Surgery Devices; Humira Patent Game; Nonprofit Hospital Tactics

February 2, 2023
Market Your Business With These National Days in February 2023 thumbnail

Market Your Business With These National Days in February 2023

February 1, 2023
Here’s How Much Emergency Cash You Should Keep at Home thumbnail

Here’s How Much Emergency Cash You Should Keep at Home

February 1, 2023
10 Strategies for Hiring and Retaining New Employees thumbnail

10 Strategies for Hiring and Retaining New Employees

February 1, 2023
House GOP prepares vote to remove Omar from committee after McCarthy finds escape hatch thumbnail

House GOP prepares vote to remove Omar from committee after McCarthy finds escape hatch

February 1, 2023
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • Donate
Friday, February 3, 2023
66 °f
Wellfleet
58 ° Tue
63 ° Wed
68 ° Thu
61 ° Fri
  • Login
  • Register
FREE Cape Cod News
DONATE
  • FREE Cape Cod News
  • News
    • News
    • Cape Cod News
    • Massachusetts
    • Breaking News
    • Cape Cod Weather
    • Storm Watch
    • Environment
  • Politics
    • democrats
    • republicans
  • Business
    • business
    • cryptocurrency
    • economy
    • money
    • Real Estate
    • Tech
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Photos
    • Orleans
    • Eastham
    • Wellfleet
    • Truro
    • Provincetown
    • Brewster
    • Chatham
  • Videos
No Result
View All Result
Free Cape Cod News
No Result
View All Result
  • FREE Cape Cod News
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Photos
  • Videos
Home Lifestyle Nature

The Trouble with Counting Alien Civilizations

FREE Cape Cod News by FREE Cape Cod News
July 20, 2020
in Nature
Reading Time: 6 mins read
Donate
0
The Trouble with Counting Alien Civilizations thumbnail
635
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on TwitterShare on Facebook

Resume Reading — The Trouble with Counting Alien Civilizations

Close


You’ve read 1 of 2 free monthly articles. Learn More.

Close

Life on Earth is a sketchy guide to intelligent life in the cosmos.

By Caleb Scharf
June 24, 2020

You might imagine that in the midst of a global pandemic and all of its social and economic fallout that our minds would be laser-focused on immediate, Earthly woes. But apparently not entirely. A case in point is the recent virus-like spread of news headlines to the effect that there should be “at least 36 alien civilizations” in our galaxy. Not 10, not a thousand, or a billion, but 36. There you have it, three dozen other sets of intelligent life dotting our cosmic neighborhood, so stick that in your pipe and smoke it.

It’s at times like these that you can almost hear the collective sigh from astronomers and astrobiologists who realize that they have to roll up their sleeves to gently, politely, carefully try to explain why these headlines are, shall we say, of the same nature as the matter that emanates from ruminant digestive systems.

Charting the development of civilizations as a simple function of the age of life on a planet seems positively ludicrous.

But I’m getting ahead of the arc here. Right now, in science, the question of whether we are alone in the universe or not is crying out for some kind of answer. Perhaps more so than at any time in recorded human history. There is a confluence of reasons for this sense of urgency and importance. For one thing we now know that planets are fantastically abundant in the universe and are potentially the best incubators of the complex chemistry associated with life as we understand it. We’re also getting closer to being able to evaluate some of these other worlds, these exoplanets, with a fidelity of data that could reveal rudimentary signatures of life, through its chemistry and the changes it wreaks on a planetary environment. Simultaneously there is a resurgence of interest in the quest to look for evidence not just of life but of technological life; either emitting structured information in radio waves or laser pulses, or sculpting its surroundings in ways that reflect intent and sophistication.

Consequently, many scientists are actively looking for ways to incorporate even the tiniest hints or clues that come from new data or insights to see if we can’t come up with statistically meaningful statements about the likelihood of life elsewhere—be it microbes or civilizations. In that sense (and I count myself in this category), we are the kids shaking the nicely wrapped presents to see if we can tell what we’re getting. The problem is that the wrapping may not come off for a long time, and that all of our guesses rest on fundamental assumptions—on prior knowledge or expectations that are themselves possibly highly biased and unusual.


Sapolsky_TH-F1

It is those assumptions that gets us back to the headline-grabbing statements about 36 alien civilizations. These headlines are based on a new study by two respectable scientists, Tom Westby and Christopher Conselice at the University of Nottingham in the United Kingdom. What these researchers actually say is that, based on a very specific calculation (that I’ll come to shortly) there is an argument to be made for the possible existence of anywhere between about half a dozen to over 200 civilizations capable of communication in our galaxy.

Arriving at those figures involves a number of steps. Some are to do with a detailed astrophysical analysis to evaluate the likely number of stars and planetary systems of particular ages and elemental compositions. It turns out, for example, that stars in our galaxy are, on average, about 9.8 billion years old—not surprisingly matching the age of the era during which most stars were formed.

But other steps involve assumptions that are extremely tricky to justify, and highly contentious. This is not to unduly criticize the study, because it is entirely open and honest about these assumptions and is a stimulating contribution to these questions. Nonetheless, the assumptions are the weak link, as are similar ones in almost every paper ever written on this topic.

In this case two “principles” are suggested: a Weak Astrobiological Copernican Principle and a Strong Astrobiological Copernican Principle. The weak one is a scenario where, because of what we witness on Earth, it is assumed that planets only form intelligent life after they reach an age of 5 billion years. The strong one says that intelligent life has to form between 4.5 and 5.5 billion years into a planet’s existence, as it seems to have on Earth. The justification for choosing these figures is that if Earth is not special (as the modern form of the Copernican Principle would have it) then we would expect other life-bearing worlds to follow suit on average. The estimated number of alien civilizations derives from these constraints, after combination with the computed statistics of exoplanets and their properties.

This is also precisely where scientific feathers get righteously ruffled. The most direct technical rebuttal to these proposed assumptions and principles is that we on Earth suffer from powerful “winner bias.” If, for example, intelligence came along much earlier or much later it would look at its history and also select its time of existence as “the most likely.”

The impetus of life toward intelligence over evolutionary time is, at best, a hypothesis.

That’s a thorny problem. But we already knew it was a problem, and there has been sophisticated work done to deploy the tools of so-called Bayesian probability to try to account for precisely this kind of bias. The results of all of those works tell us that we are truly, quantifiably ignorant about life’s most probable trajectory, and that our Earth-based data points have very limited discriminatory power.

The other rebuttal, that is in many ways far more interesting, is to do with our impressive ignorance about the very nature of life itself, and the nature of the phenomenon we blithely call “intelligence.” Because of that ignorance, charting the development of civilizations as a simple function of the age of life on a planet seems positively ludicrous.

What we do have is an emerging sense that life and its planetary environment are inextricably entwined. Every piece of Earth’s deep environmental history is a complicated story of the interactions and interdependencies of life and planet; of geochemistry and biogeochemistry. As a result, the trajectory of life here may only be partially reproducible anywhere else in the cosmos—even assuming the same chemical toolkit, the same information-bearing molecular structures and biochemistry, and the same rules of selection and evolution.

The nature of intelligence, or technological capacity, also tends to be conflated with the idea that life, on average, seems to become more complex over time. It has been posited that the improvements of prediction that complexity enables (the projection abilities of neural nets and brains) is one item at the root of this tendency. If an organism can guess the future better it ought to survive better. But, of course, there are living forms, from bacteria to plant life, that have remained largely unchanged for hundreds of millions, even billions, of years. If something works in biology there seems to be little need for it to change. The impetus of life toward intelligence over evolutionary time is, at best, a hypothesis.

In short, any assumptions about properties like intelligence or agency that we make based on what we currently know about life on Earth are on exceedingly shaky ground. To import those assumptions to quantitative analyses of the likelihood of civilizations elsewhere seems like a stretch in most cases. Although there is value to the intellectual exercise as preparation for when the time comes that we, perhaps, have more data to go by.

And perhaps too there is value to anything that, in the days and nights of the coming months, causes us to momentarily pause and think about the bigger picture. To find a little respite by contemplating the endlessly tumbling stories of societies and civilizations as they unfold across cosmic time.

Caleb Scharf is an astrophysicist, the Director of Astrobiology at Columbia University in New York, and a founder of yhousenyc.org, an institute that studies human and machine consciousness. His latest book is The Zoomable Universe: An Epic Tour Through Cosmic Scale, from Almost Everything to Nearly Nothing.

Lead image: Dotted Yeti / Shutterstock

FREE Digital Newspaper Subscription!
Sign up for your free digital subscription. The FREE Cape Cod News

Unsubscribe
FREE Cape Cod News

FREE Cape Cod News

Free Cape Cod News is what's happening in the Cape Cod, U.S and World & what people are talking about right now. Local newspaper. Stay in the know. Subscribe to get notified about our latest news.

Related Posts

EV adoption doesn’t lighten energy costs for all American families thumbnail
Nature

EV adoption doesn’t lighten energy costs for all American families

by FREE Cape Cod News
January 29, 2023
The science behind seasonal depression thumbnail
Fitness / Health

The science behind seasonal depression

by FREE Cape Cod News
January 28, 2023
One wormy Triassic fossil could fill a hole in the evolutionary story of amphibians thumbnail
Nature

One wormy Triassic fossil could fill a hole in the evolutionary story of amphibians

by FREE Cape Cod News
January 26, 2023
“Unusual mortality event”: Climate concerns rise after dead whales keep washing up on beaches thumbnail
Environment

“Unusual mortality event”: Climate concerns rise after dead whales keep washing up on beaches

by FREE Cape Cod News
January 20, 2023
Load More
Please login to join discussion

Follow Us on Twitter

FREE Cape Cod News - Your source for local Cape Cod news, latest breaking U.S. and World news. Every day, all day. Subscribe for your favorite categories.

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Joe Biden Offered Vladimir Putin 20 Percent of Ukraine to End War: Report thumbnail

Joe Biden Offered Vladimir Putin 20 Percent of Ukraine to End War: Report

February 3, 2023
Epstein's Modeling Scout Pal Jean-Luc Brunel Detained on Suspicion of Rape and Trafficking thumbnail

Epstein’s Modeling Scout Pal Jean-Luc Brunel Detained on Suspicion of Rape and Trafficking

December 18, 2020
Trump to sign executive orders protecting preexisting conditions and seeking a way to prevent surprise medical bills thumbnail

Trump to sign executive orders protecting preexisting conditions and seeking a way to prevent surprise medical bills

September 25, 2020
Record cold snap could hit New England this weekend thumbnail

Record cold snap could hit New England this weekend

February 3, 2023
Joe Biden Offered Vladimir Putin 20 Percent of Ukraine to End War: Report thumbnail

Joe Biden Offered Vladimir Putin 20 Percent of Ukraine to End War: Report

February 3, 2023
GoodRx fined $1.5 million for allegedly selling users’ health data thumbnail

GoodRx fined $1.5 million for allegedly selling users’ health data

February 3, 2023

FREE Cape Cod News On Twitter

Today’s News

  • Record cold snap could hit New England this weekend February 3, 2023
  • Joe Biden Offered Vladimir Putin 20 Percent of Ukraine to End War: Report February 3, 2023
  • GoodRx fined $1.5 million for allegedly selling users’ health data February 3, 2023
  • Small Businesses Lost 75,000 Jobs in January February 2, 2023
  • DARPA wants to push the boundaries of where satellites can fly February 2, 2023
FREE Cape Cod News

Copyright © 2022 Free Cape Cod News

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • Donate

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • FREE Cape Cod News
  • News
    • News
    • Cape Cod News
    • Massachusetts
    • Breaking News
    • Cape Cod Weather
    • Storm Watch
    • Environment
  • Politics
    • democrats
    • republicans
  • Business
    • business
    • cryptocurrency
    • economy
    • money
    • Real Estate
    • Tech
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Photos
    • Orleans
    • Eastham
    • Wellfleet
    • Truro
    • Provincetown
    • Brewster
    • Chatham
  • Videos
  • Login
  • Sign Up

Copyright © 2022 Free Cape Cod News

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist