• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Lifestyle
The Whiners Who Earn $200,000 and Complain They’re Broke thumbnail

The Whiners Who Earn $200,000 and Complain They’re Broke

July 22, 2020
The Hunter Biden Testimony James Comer Doesn’t Want You to See thumbnail

The Hunter Biden Testimony James Comer Doesn’t Want You to See

November 30, 2023
White House puts corporate 'price gouging' front and center: 'We see American families hurting' thumbnail

White House puts corporate ‘price gouging’ front and center: ‘We see American families hurting’

November 30, 2023
Ex-Binance Chief CZ Must Stay In U.S. After Guilty Plea—For Now thumbnail

Ex-Binance Chief CZ Must Stay In U.S. After Guilty Plea—For Now

November 29, 2023
3 men of Palestinian descent attending holiday gathering shot, injured near University of Vermont thumbnail

3 men of Palestinian descent attending holiday gathering shot, injured near University of Vermont

November 28, 2023
No Americans Included in Hamas Hostage Release Puts Biden in GOP Crosshairs thumbnail

No Americans Included in Hamas Hostage Release Puts Biden in GOP Crosshairs

November 27, 2023
How animals get their skin patterns is a matter of physics thumbnail

How animals get their skin patterns is a matter of physics

November 27, 2023
Republicans’ views of the economy are completely detached from reality thumbnail

Republicans’ views of the economy are completely detached from reality

November 26, 2023
America’s Religious-Political Divide Could Threaten its Future, Gallup Scientist Warns thumbnail

America’s Religious-Political Divide Could Threaten its Future, Gallup Scientist Warns

November 25, 2023
The IRS delayed its controversial new policy regarding digital payment platforms thumbnail

The IRS delayed its controversial new policy regarding digital payment platforms

November 25, 2023
Thanks to Bidenomics, Your Thanksgiving Costs 110% of 2020's; On the Bright Side, You're Making Less thumbnail

Thanks to Bidenomics, Your Thanksgiving Costs 110% of 2020’s; On the Bright Side, You’re Making Less

November 25, 2023
A controversial US surveillance program is up for renewal. Critics are speaking out. thumbnail

A controversial US surveillance program is up for renewal. Critics are speaking out.

November 23, 2023
The Republicans Pushing To Investigate The Jan 6 Investigators All Played Parts In Efforts To Overturn The 2020 Election thumbnail

The Republicans Pushing To Investigate The Jan 6 Investigators All Played Parts In Efforts To Overturn The 2020 Election

November 23, 2023
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • Donate
Thursday, November 30, 2023
66 °f
Wellfleet
58 ° Tue
63 ° Wed
68 ° Thu
61 ° Fri
  • Login
  • Register
FREE Cape Cod News
DONATE
  • FREE Cape Cod News
  • Cape Cod News
  • News
    • News
    • Massachusetts
    • Breaking News
    • Cape Cod Weather
    • Storm Watch
    • Environment
  • Politics
    • democrats
    • republicans
  • Business
    • business
    • cryptocurrency
    • economy
    • money
    • Real Estate
    • Tech
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Photos
    • Orleans
    • Eastham
    • Wellfleet
    • Truro
    • Provincetown
    • Brewster
    • Chatham
  • Videos
No Result
View All Result
Free Cape Cod News
No Result
View All Result
  • FREE Cape Cod News
  • Cape Cod News
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Photos
  • Videos
Home Lifestyle

The Whiners Who Earn $200,000 and Complain They’re Broke

FREE Cape Cod News by FREE Cape Cod News
July 22, 2020
in Lifestyle
Reading Time: 9 mins read
Donate
0
The Whiners Who Earn $200,000 and Complain They’re Broke thumbnail
633
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on TwitterShare on Facebook

On July 11, MarketWatch published a letter, presumably real, from a reader complaining that she and her husband didn’t qualify for a stimulus payment because they make too much money. Said the upset letter writer:

I don’t feel that earning $200,000 a year should be too much to qualify under the CARES Act. I believe they need to raise the income threshold to $300,000 or $400,000 a year, or not have any income guidelines. After all, people who are making nothing or very little are receiving this money, so why can’t the people who are paying the most taxes receive some of it back? What bothers me the most is that most of these families look a lot like ours, but they chose to not marry or they file separately. I earn less than $50,000, but my spouse earns barely over $150,000 a year.

These kinds of poor-mouth complaints from people who are well-to-do by any reasonable standard are not by any means new. Starting with the rise of Andrew Jackson, practically every presidential contender in the nineteenth century claimed to be born in a log cabin. The New York Times, The Washington Post, Town & Country, and other publications that cater to the rich and upper-middle class have long published articles about the alleged economic struggles of high-earning people in costly urban centers.

For example, in 2009, the Times published a piece that did not appear to be tongue-in-cheek about how tough it was to get by on an income of $500,000 in New York City. (If this article were to run today, the figure would be moved up to $600,000 to adjust for inflation.) The article, appearing in the opening throes of the Great Recession, laid out the many expenses eating away at this lavish-seeming nest egg: This family would probably have a mortgage payment of $96,000 plus an additional co-op maintenance fee of $96,000. There would also be $32,000 in private school tuition per child and $45,000 for a nanny. That comes to $269,000 a year on an after-tax income of just $293,000. Throw in food, clothing, vacations, and other reasonable costs, and it’s not hard to see how little half a million dollars of gross income can get you, if you’re invested in the high-life amenities that define the lifestyle of the top one percent of Americans.

Several other straight-faced accounts of the high-earner’s plight have likewise focused on families making $500,000. One financial adviser posted the budget of a family he knew personally that spent $271,100 on a net income of $278,400. It included $42,000 for childcare, $18,000 for vacations, and $12,000 for sports and music lessons for the children. The family appeared to have just $7,300 for saving at the end of the year.

But the numbers that make up such litanies are more than a little fuzzy. For example, any economist looking at this budget would immediately notice that the adviser subtracted the $36,000 contributed to 401(k) accounts as an expense, rather than saving. Nor is there any mention of investment income or home equity. On the other hand, the family apparently was putting away nothing for their children’s college education, and the parents were still paying $32,000 on their own student loans. Perhaps they simply assumed that loans would cover their children’s education as well.

The phenomenon of wealthy people who lack liquidity and therefore essentially live hand-to-mouth is now so prevalent that economists are studying its macroeconomic effects. Historically, economists have assumed that rich people will spend very little out of any income increase because they can already afford whatever they want. But if the rich are constrained by a lack of cash flow, they may spend a considerable portion of any income increase, which would raise short-run growth. Indeed, there are reports that a sharp slowdown in spending by the rich is a key factor in the recent economic slowdown.

Pollsters periodically ask people about who they think belongs in various social classes, based on income. According to Gallup, only 2 percent of Americans historically have put themselves in the upper class, with 16 percent in the upper-middle class, 43 percent in the middle class, 30 percent in the working class, and just 9 percent calling themselves poor. Gallup data also shows that people’s perceptions of what income puts people in what class vary a lot. As the first chart demonstrates, practically every income group includes people who consider themselves as belonging to every other social class. The Gallup findings are confirmed by YouGov data.



There are many reasons why someone who appears to be poor or middle class, objectively, might nevertheless put themselves in a higher social class. They could be children of the well-to-do who are temporarily making little income or expect an inheritance to pull them up at some point. They may be people with degrees from good schools whose perception of their social class is based on their prospects rather than their current circumstances. Or they may hold high-status jobs in fields like journalism or book publishing that don’t necessarily pay very much. They may also be retirees, whose income is relatively low but who have considerable wealth they can draw upon. Indeed, retirees are generally better off financially than nonretirees, elderly homeowners tend to have substantial home equity, and about half don’t even have a mortgage.

The issue of wealth versus income is critical to perceptions of social class and general well-being. A 2019 study by Charles Schwab found that it took at least $2.3 million in wealth to be considered reasonably rich. Perceptions of wealth are also self-fueled to no small degree, since the wealthier people become, the more wealth they think they need to be considered rich. A 2011 survey of millionaires by Fidelity Investments found that they thought they needed at least $7.5 million to feel rich. Yet there are those with very considerably more wealth than that who will nevertheless insist that they are just ordinary middle-class people.

In 2012, Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romney’s wife, Ann, said she didn’t consider herself to be wealthy despite a net worth of $250 million and $22 million of income the previous year. In 2015, New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, then running for the GOP presidential nomination, also denied being wealthy, even though his investment banker wife made more than $700,000 on top of his salary as governor.

Absurdly, there are even billionaires who refuse to admit that they are rich. Tom Steyer is one. Of course, he was running for the Democratic presidential nomination and probably felt that it was politically expedient to downplay his wealth. But Republican billionaires also push back against any suggestion that they might be deemed ultrawealthy. Billionaire Florida auto dealer Norman Braman, a big supporter of Senator Marco Rubio, insisted in a 2015 interview that he was not especially wealthy or important. “I don’t consider myself a fat cat,” he said. “Don’t make me out to be a fat cat.”

The question of who is wealthy and who isn’t has political implications that go well beyond electoral politics; it is important for tax policy, among other things. Republicans are always keen to stretch the definition of “middle class” to include as many rich people as possible, because it’s easier to sell tax cuts for the middle class than for the wealthy. Democrats, on the other hand, are always looking to lower the threshold for being rich when proposing tax increases—since, conversely, it’s easier to enact higher taxes on the rich than on the actually existing middle class. If the income cutoff at the lower end of the well-to-do rung is set too high, there is less revenue available.

Social scientists are also exploring what might be called the existential facets of wealth. One such researcher is Rachel Sherman of the New School for Social Research, who has written a book on the subject, Uneasy Street: The Anxieties of Affluence. She conducted intensive interviews with 50 very affluent New Yorkers to see how their wealth affected their lives beyond the obvious ability to own lots of stuff. Many were very concerned about the depiction of them as unworthy of their wealth; to dispute that notion, they tended to emphasize how hard they worked for it. And most went to great lengths to keep their children grounded and not see themselves as excessively privileged. As Sherman writes:

In this climate, it is hard to feel that being wealthy is compatible with being morally worthy, and the wealthy themselves are well aware of the problem. The parents I talked with struggle over how to raise kids who deserve their privilege, encouraging them to become hard workers and disciplined consumers. They often talked about keeping kids “normal,” using language that invoked broad “middle-class” American values. At the same time, they wanted to make sure that their children could prevail in increasingly competitive education and labour markets. This dilemma led to a profound tension between limiting and fostering privilege.

In Democracy in America, Alexis de Tocqueville noted the propensity of wealthy people to see themselves as part of the broad middle class, rather than as aristocrats like those in Europe. He thought that the mobility of wealth in America, both up and down, was the reason. “The rich daily rise out of the crowd and constantly return thither,” he said. Unfortunately, the growth of economic inequality increasingly calls that assumption into question.

Poor-mouthing by the wealthy may be a matter of interest to researchers, but no one should lose sight of the fact that rich people’s problems are trivial compared to those facing the poor and working class. In an increasingly class-segmented America, facing the prospect of a long economic downturn, the complaints to take seriously come from our fellow citizens who lack jobs, health insurance, decent housing, quality educations, and many, many other things that the wealthy simply take for granted.

FREE Digital Newspaper Subscription!
Sign up for your free digital subscription. The FREE Cape Cod News

Unsubscribe
FREE Cape Cod News

FREE Cape Cod News

Free Cape Cod News is what's happening in the Cape Cod, U.S and World & what people are talking about right now. Local newspaper. Stay in the know. Subscribe to get notified about our latest news.

Related Posts

How animals get their skin patterns is a matter of physics thumbnail
Nature

How animals get their skin patterns is a matter of physics

by FREE Cape Cod News
November 27, 2023
Nearly 450 hospital patients in Massachusetts could have been exposed to hepatitis and HIV thumbnail
Fitness / Health

Nearly 450 hospital patients in Massachusetts could have been exposed to hepatitis and HIV

by FREE Cape Cod News
November 19, 2023
Surge in Vaccine Lawsuits Forces Biden Admin to Hire More Attorneys thumbnail
Coronavirus

Surge in Vaccine Lawsuits Forces Biden Admin to Hire More Attorneys

by FREE Cape Cod News
November 16, 2023
An American Paradise in the Caribbean thumbnail
Lifestyle

An American Paradise in the Caribbean

by FREE Cape Cod News
November 10, 2023
Load More
Please login to join discussion

Follow Us on Twitter

FREE Cape Cod News - Your source for local Cape Cod news, latest breaking U.S. and World news. Every day, all day. Subscribe for your favorite categories.

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
The Hunter Biden Testimony James Comer Doesn’t Want You to See thumbnail

The Hunter Biden Testimony James Comer Doesn’t Want You to See

November 30, 2023
Cape Cod Treasure in a bottle on Cape Cod National Seashore. FREE Cape Cod News.

Will Cape Cod Be Underwater in the Future?

April 29, 2023
White House puts corporate 'price gouging' front and center: 'We see American families hurting' thumbnail

White House puts corporate ‘price gouging’ front and center: ‘We see American families hurting’

November 30, 2023
The Hunter Biden Testimony James Comer Doesn’t Want You to See thumbnail

The Hunter Biden Testimony James Comer Doesn’t Want You to See

November 30, 2023
White House puts corporate 'price gouging' front and center: 'We see American families hurting' thumbnail

White House puts corporate ‘price gouging’ front and center: ‘We see American families hurting’

November 30, 2023
Ex-Binance Chief CZ Must Stay In U.S. After Guilty Plea—For Now thumbnail

Ex-Binance Chief CZ Must Stay In U.S. After Guilty Plea—For Now

November 29, 2023

FREE Cape Cod News On Twitter

Today’s News

  • The Hunter Biden Testimony James Comer Doesn’t Want You to See November 30, 2023
  • White House puts corporate ‘price gouging’ front and center: ‘We see American families hurting’ November 30, 2023
  • Ex-Binance Chief CZ Must Stay In U.S. After Guilty Plea—For Now November 29, 2023
  • 3 men of Palestinian descent attending holiday gathering shot, injured near University of Vermont November 28, 2023
  • No Americans Included in Hamas Hostage Release Puts Biden in GOP Crosshairs November 27, 2023
FREE Cape Cod News

Copyright © 2023 Free Cape Cod News

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • Donate

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • FREE Cape Cod News
  • Cape Cod News
  • News
    • News
    • Massachusetts
    • Breaking News
    • Cape Cod Weather
    • Storm Watch
    • Environment
  • Politics
    • democrats
    • republicans
  • Business
    • business
    • cryptocurrency
    • economy
    • money
    • Real Estate
    • Tech
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Photos
    • Orleans
    • Eastham
    • Wellfleet
    • Truro
    • Provincetown
    • Brewster
    • Chatham
  • Videos
  • Login
  • Sign Up

Copyright © 2023 Free Cape Cod News

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist