• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Lifestyle
How to Fix America’s Broken Guest-Worker System thumbnail

How to Fix America’s Broken Guest-Worker System

July 19, 2020
Where to Celebrate Oktoberfest This Fall thumbnail

Where to Celebrate Oktoberfest This Fall

September 21, 2023
China’s foreign minister heads to Moscow after meeting with U.S. national security adviser thumbnail

China’s foreign minister heads to Moscow after meeting with U.S. national security adviser

September 21, 2023
Treating high blood pressure can save 76 million lives in 30 years, WHO says thumbnail

Treating high blood pressure can save 76 million lives in 30 years, WHO says

September 21, 2023
Do pets really make people happier and healthier? thumbnail

Do pets really make people happier and healthier?

September 21, 2023
Republicans Are Losing Their Mind Over the Senate’s New Dress Code thumbnail

Republicans Are Losing Their Mind Over the Senate’s New Dress Code

September 20, 2023
What is a Cybersecurity Policy and How to Create One? thumbnail

What is a Cybersecurity Policy and How to Create One?

September 20, 2023
Whistleblower Lawyer Slams Hunter Biden Lawsuit Against the IRS for 'Violation of Rights' thumbnail

Whistleblower Lawyer Slams Hunter Biden Lawsuit Against the IRS for ‘Violation of Rights’

September 20, 2023
Norfolk Southern to pay Ohio town residents for any lost home value after a train crash and resulting health worries decimated the local economy thumbnail

Norfolk Southern to pay Ohio town residents for any lost home value after a train crash and resulting health worries decimated the local economy

September 20, 2023
Family says 14-year-old daughter targeted by crew after camera phone discovered in airline toilet thumbnail

Family says 14-year-old daughter targeted by crew after camera phone discovered in airline toilet

September 20, 2023
2 ways of knowing if there are PFAS in your drinking water thumbnail

2 ways of knowing if there are PFAS in your drinking water

September 19, 2023
House Democrats press for cameras in federal courts thumbnail

House Democrats press for cameras in federal courts

September 19, 2023
Kevin McCarthy Announces House Republicans Will Subpoena Hunter Biden in Impeachment Inquiry thumbnail

Kevin McCarthy Announces House Republicans Will Subpoena Hunter Biden in Impeachment Inquiry

September 19, 2023
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • Donate
Friday, September 22, 2023
66 °f
Wellfleet
58 ° Tue
63 ° Wed
68 ° Thu
61 ° Fri
  • Login
  • Register
FREE Cape Cod News
DONATE
  • FREE Cape Cod News
  • Cape Cod News
  • News
    • News
    • Massachusetts
    • Breaking News
    • Cape Cod Weather
    • Storm Watch
    • Environment
  • Politics
    • democrats
    • republicans
  • Business
    • business
    • cryptocurrency
    • economy
    • money
    • Real Estate
    • Tech
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Photos
    • Orleans
    • Eastham
    • Wellfleet
    • Truro
    • Provincetown
    • Brewster
    • Chatham
  • Videos
No Result
View All Result
Free Cape Cod News
No Result
View All Result
  • FREE Cape Cod News
  • Cape Cod News
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Photos
  • Videos
Home Cape Cod News

How to Fix America’s Broken Guest-Worker System

FREE Cape Cod News by FREE Cape Cod News
July 19, 2020
in Cape Cod News
Reading Time: 6 mins read
Donate
1
How to Fix America’s Broken Guest-Worker System thumbnail
636
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on TwitterShare on Facebook

There’s an understandably strong temptation to condemn President Donald Trump for suspending guest-worker visas through the end of 2020. His executive order is far too sweeping, it invites retaliation by other nations, and there’s a stark underlying hypocrisy in Trump’s seizing the pretext of the coronavirus pandemic as a matter of grave concern while he pretends in just about every other context that the health crisis is abating, which it isn’t.

But the truth is that even those of us who take an expansive view of immigration’s benefits to society and the economy get a little queasy when the subject turns to guest-worker programs. As the left-leaning Economic Policy Institute noted in a 2018 report, such programs tend to leave migrant workers “vulnerable to exploitation and abuse” and employers altogether too “reliant on temporary, low-wage migrant labor.”

Consider H-2B visas, which are issued to nonagricultural seasonal workers. Some of these visas go to bright-eyed young foreigners who want to see the United States and are willing to pay for it by spending a summer ladling clam chowder to vacationers on Cape Cod. But most H-2B visas go to foreign workers in very low-wage occupations like landscaping, groundskeeping, and seafood processing. (The Trump Organization has depended heavily on H-2B labor at Trump’s various resorts, including Mar-a-Lago and the Trump National Golf Club in Jupiter, Florida.)

In theory, employers pay H-2B guest workers the prevailing wage, but in practice, the Department of Labor, which supervises the program, “authorizes employers to essentially price-fix a depressed wage rate for these jobs,” according to a 2017 Stanford Law & Policy Review article by Jennifer J. Lee, a law professor at Temple University. It’s hard to imagine the arrangement going any other way: Before hiring an H-2B guest worker, an employer must certify to the Labor Department that no Americans can be found to do the job. If no American will do the job, then the only comparable work on which to base a prevailing wage is the labor performed either by other guest workers or by undocumented workers. So it’s no surprise that H-2B workers end up earning about the same wage as undocumented immigrants. If anything, undocumented immigrants fare a little better, because they can quit one employer to work for another; H-2B workers are stuck with whoever sponsored them.

It’s probably true that H-2B visa-holders perform work that others won’t, but this is a self-fulfilling prophecy. Before H-2B visas were invented in the 1986 Simpson-Mazzoli immigration law, somebody was clipping hedges and picking crabs, right? Whoever that somebody was stopped applying for these jobs as wages fell and word got around that the money that could be earned was fit only for destitute foreigners.

Just about everything that can be said about H-2B visas is also true of H-2A visas, which go to guest workers in agriculture. The regulatory apparatus for H-2A workers was created by the same Simpson-Mazzoli law, and the rules are very similar to those for H-2B workers. But Trump has exempted H-2A workers from the visa suspension because his administration deems them essential workers—itself a profound irony, given Trump’s frequent insistence that America doesn’t need foreign workers to get by.

In addition to H-2B visas, Trump has suspended J-1 visas “to the extent that the alien is participating in an intern, trainee, teacher, camp counselor, au pair, or summer work travel program.” This is much harder to defend. The suspension sets up an unfair barrier for foreign students who need to work and poses a serious problem for higher education, which depends heavily on these students’ highly skilled labor, especially in the sciences.

The au pair program, though, could use a kick in the pants. Beloved by the haute bourgeoisie because it furnishes inexpensive live-in labor to care for their children—I myself was once a grateful beneficiary—its classification as a cultural exchange program rather than a work program leaves its administration in the hands of the State Department, which, as exposé after exposé has demonstrated, has little interest in monitoring the horrific abuses that some families dish out, or ability to do so. Given the enormous political power of the program’s constituency, this is the likeliest part of Trump’s executive order to be reversed—indeed, the early word before the order was finalized was that au pairs were to be excluded. The truth is, however, that the program could use a time-out while Congress figures out how to transfer its administration from Foggy Bottom to the Labor Department.

The visa suspension that’s created the most howls of outrage concerns highly skilled H-1B workers. Apple CEO Tim Cook took to Twitter to pronounce himself “deeply disappointed,” and The Verge bewailed that “tech companies accounted for roughly two-thirds of the total visas.”

That’s not exactly right. Roughly two-thirds of H-1B workers are in “computer-related occupations,” but the majority of H-1B visas go to contractors that provide foreign workers to perform tech jobs (many of them not terribly high-skilled) for companies of all kinds. The distinction is important because if Company A (say, Pacific Gas & Electric or perhaps AT&T) fires Worker B and requires him to train Guest Worker C as a condition of receiving severance, it’s all perfectly legal, so long as Guest Worker C is employed not by Company A but rather by a business to which Company A contracted out the work. All of this passes legal muster because Company A didn’t replace Worker B with a guest worker; rather, it eliminated his or her job entirely and assigned a separate company to provide the labor.

The contracting companies are typically Indian, and typically they have no interest (as, say Apple or Microsoft might) in finding a way to keep Guest Worker C in the U.S. These firms prefer instead to send Guest Worker C back to India, the better to take advantage of the valuable job training he or she acquired in the States.

The Trump administration has cracked down, to some extent, on abuse of this loophole, particularly on the Indian companies Tata and Infosys, which have dominated the H-1B market in the past. But Tata still ranks third in H-1B approvals, and Infosys sixth, the Economic Policy Institute reported in May, and half the companies in the top 30 still “have an outsourcing business model.” Sixty percent of H-1B visa holders are paid below the local median wage for that occupation, the EPI found.

By all means, don’t let’s turn away foreign workers. We must shelter them generously, welcome their enterprise, and provide them with opportunity and a chance at a prosperous life. But the current guest-worker model isn’t cutting it. The H-2B, J-1, and H-1B visa programs are to varying degrees corrupt, and if suspending them encourages a future presidential administration to reform or replace them, then everyone involved will be much better off.

FREE Digital Newspaper Subscription!
Sign up for your free digital subscription. The FREE Cape Cod News

Unsubscribe
FREE Cape Cod News

FREE Cape Cod News

Free Cape Cod News is what's happening in the Cape Cod, U.S and World & what people are talking about right now. Local newspaper. Stay in the know. Subscribe to get notified about our latest news.

Related Posts

Cape Cod: Killer identified in Massachusetts "Lady of the Dunes" cold case thumbnail
Cape Cod News

Cape Cod: Killer identified in Massachusetts “Lady of the Dunes” cold case

by FREE Cape Cod News
August 31, 2023
Study: 800 great white sharks have visited Cape Cod in recent years thumbnail
Cape Cod News

Study: 800 great white sharks have visited Cape Cod in recent years

by FREE Cape Cod News
July 30, 2023
Drinking and Boating in Massachusetts. Free Cape Cod News.
Cape Cod News

Drinking and Boating in Massachusetts

by FREE Cape Cod News
July 23, 2023
Cape Cod Traffic
Cape Cod News

Avoid Cape Cod Traffic Jams: Insider Tips for Leaving the Cape After Vacation Without Hitting Major Delays

by FREE Cape Cod News
July 21, 2023
Load More
Please login to join discussion

Follow Us on Twitter

FREE Cape Cod News - Your source for local Cape Cod news, latest breaking U.S. and World news. Every day, all day. Subscribe for your favorite categories.

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Cape Cod Real Estate Bubble

Will the Cape Cod Real Estate Bubble Burst in 2024? The Answer is a Resounding Yes!

April 30, 2023
Where to Celebrate Oktoberfest This Fall thumbnail

Where to Celebrate Oktoberfest This Fall

September 21, 2023
Samuel L. Jackson Hits Trump, GOP With ‘Vote, Dammit, Vote’ Video thumbnail

Samuel L. Jackson Hits Trump, GOP With ‘Vote, Dammit, Vote’ Video

October 10, 2020
Where to Celebrate Oktoberfest This Fall thumbnail

Where to Celebrate Oktoberfest This Fall

September 21, 2023
China’s foreign minister heads to Moscow after meeting with U.S. national security adviser thumbnail

China’s foreign minister heads to Moscow after meeting with U.S. national security adviser

September 21, 2023
Treating high blood pressure can save 76 million lives in 30 years, WHO says thumbnail

Treating high blood pressure can save 76 million lives in 30 years, WHO says

September 21, 2023

FREE Cape Cod News On Twitter

Today’s News

  • Where to Celebrate Oktoberfest This Fall September 21, 2023
  • China’s foreign minister heads to Moscow after meeting with U.S. national security adviser September 21, 2023
  • Treating high blood pressure can save 76 million lives in 30 years, WHO says September 21, 2023
  • Do pets really make people happier and healthier? September 21, 2023
  • Republicans Are Losing Their Mind Over the Senate’s New Dress Code September 20, 2023
FREE Cape Cod News

Copyright © 2023 Free Cape Cod News

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • Donate

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • FREE Cape Cod News
  • Cape Cod News
  • News
    • News
    • Massachusetts
    • Breaking News
    • Cape Cod Weather
    • Storm Watch
    • Environment
  • Politics
    • democrats
    • republicans
  • Business
    • business
    • cryptocurrency
    • economy
    • money
    • Real Estate
    • Tech
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Photos
    • Orleans
    • Eastham
    • Wellfleet
    • Truro
    • Provincetown
    • Brewster
    • Chatham
  • Videos
  • Login
  • Sign Up

Copyright © 2023 Free Cape Cod News

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist